Older Teens' Understanding and Perceptions of Risks in Studies With Genetic Testing: A Pilot Study.

Authors:
Richard F Ittenbach
Richard F Ittenbach
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center
Cincinnati | United States
Robert V Miller
Robert V Miller
Oklahoma State University
Stillwater | United States

AJOB Empir Bioeth 2019 Apr 19:1-9. Epub 2019 Apr 19.

d Academic and Regulatory Monitoring Services, LLC , Cincinnati , Ohio , USA.

Background: The consent process used in clinical research today falls markedly short of the ideal process envisioned nearly 30 years ago. Critics have suggested that the informed consent process has become challenging, formalistic, and incompletely understood by researchers and participants alike. Hence, the purpose of this pilot study was to identify and characterize important aspects of the informed consent process that teens believe impact their understanding of risks of participation in studies with genetic testing.

Methods: The personal research experiences of 15 teens regarding consent/assent and research participation in studies with genetic testing were solicited through focus-group interviews. All participants had enrolled in at least one research study involving genetic testing in the prior 2 years. All groups were facilitated by the same experienced focus-group moderator. Themes and subthemes were identified, summarized, and interpreted using conventional qualitative content analysis.

Results: Three overarching themes emerged from the interviews: fear of what could happen, need for additional information regarding risks, and need for autonomy and decision-making control throughout the consent process.

Conclusion: Results of this pilot study provide preliminary evidence that teens can identify and characterize key issues in the informed consent/assent process when it comes to the risks of research participation. These findings are consistent with other research regarding teens' perceptions and recommendations for genetic testing research.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/23294515.2019.1577313DOI Listing
April 2019

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

genetic testing
16
consent process
12
studies genetic
12
pilot study
12
participation studies
8
informed consent
8
risks participation
8
identify characterize
8
process
5
genetic
5
consent/assent participation
4
study provide
4
teens consent/assent
4
study involving
4
testing solicited
4
experiences teens
4
processconclusion pilot
4
focus-group interviews
4
interviews participants
4
solicited focus-group
4

References

(Supplied by CrossRef)
Article in Clinical Trials
Chen S. C. et al.
Clinical Trials 2016

Creswell J. W. et al.
2018
Article in Federal Register
DHHS et al.
Federal Register 2017
Article in IRB
Kripalani S. et al.
IRB 2008
Article in BMC Medical Ethics
Lie R. K. et al.
BMC Medical Ethics 2017

Similar Publications