Reply to Duffy and Smith's (2018) reexamination.

Psychon Bull Rev 2019 Apr;26(2):693-698

University of Richmond, Richmond, VA, USA.

Duffy, Huttenlocher, Hedges, and Crawford (2010, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 17[2], 224-230) examined whether the well-established central tendency bias in people's reproductions of stimuli reflects bias toward the mean of an entire presented distribution or bias toward only recently seen stimuli. They reported evidence that responses were biased toward the long-run mean and found no evidence that they were biased toward the most recent stimuli. Duffy and Smith (2018) reexamine the data using a different analytical strategy and argue that estimates are biased by recent stimuli rather than toward the long-run mean. I argue that this reanalysis misses a true effect of the running mean and that the data are (mostly) consistent with the claims in the original work. I suggest that these results, and many other null results presented by Duffy and Smith, do not have major theoretical significance for the category adjustment model and similar Bayesian models. (Code and data available: https://osf.io/tkqvn .).

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.3758/s13423-019-01592-yDOI Listing
April 2019
5 Reads

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

duffy smith
8
biased stimuli
8
data analytical
4
reexamine data
4
2018 reexamine
4
smith 2018
4
analytical strategy
4
strategy argue
4
stimuli long-run
4
estimates biased
4
argue estimates
4
entire presented
4
stimuli duffy
4
reported evidence
4
stimuli reported
4
bias stimuli
4
distribution bias
4
evidence responses
4
responses biased
4
long-run argue
4

References

(Supplied by CrossRef)
Article in Journal of Statistical Software
D Bates et al.
Journal of Statistical Software 2015

GEP Box et al.
1979
Article in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
JM Choplin et al.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2002

JA Cornell et al.
2011
Article in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition
LE Crawford et al.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition 2016
Article in Memory & Cognition
S Duffy et al.
Memory & Cognition 2008
Article in Developmental Science
S Duffy et al.
Developmental Science 2006
Article in Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
S Duffy et al.
Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2010
Article in Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
S Duffy et al.
Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2018
Article in Psychological Review
J Huttenlocher et al.
Psychological Review 1991
Article in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
J Huttenlocher et al.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2000

Similar Publications