Five system barriers to achieving ultrasafe health care.

Authors:
Dr Paul Barach, BSc, MD, MPH
Dr Paul Barach, BSc, MD, MPH
Wayne State University School of Medicine
Clinical Professor
Anesthesia, critical care
Chicago, IL | United States

Ann Intern Med 2005 May;142(9):756-64

Cognitive Science Department, Brétigny-sur-Orge, France.

Although debate continues over estimates of the amount of preventable medical harm that occurs in health care, there seems to be a consensus that health care is not as safe and reliable as it might be. It is often assumed that copying and adapting the success stories of nonmedical industries, such as civil aviation and nuclear power, will make medicine as safe as these industries. However, the solution is not that simple. This article explains why a benchmarking approach to safety in high-risk industries is needed to help translate lessons so that they are usable and long lasting in health care. The most important difference among industries lies not so much in the pertinent safety toolkit, which is similar for most industries, but in an industry's willingness to abandon historical and cultural precedents and beliefs that are linked to performance and autonomy, in a constant drive toward a culture of safety. Five successive systemic barriers currently prevent health care from becoming an ultrasafe industrial system: the need to limit the discretion of workers, the need to reduce worker autonomy, the need to make the transition from a craftsmanship mindset to that of equivalent actors, the need for system-level (senior leadership) arbitration to optimize safety strategies, and the need for simplification. Finally, health care must overcome 3 unique problems: a wide range of risk among medical specialties, difficulty in defining medical error, and various structural constraints (such as public demand, teaching role, and chronic shortage of staff). Without such a framework to guide development, ongoing efforts to improve safety by adopting the safety strategies of other industries may yield reduced dividends. Rapid progress is possible only if the health care industry is willing to address these structural constraints needed to overcome the 5 barriers to ultrasafe performance.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-142-9-200505030-00012DOI Listing
May 2005
36 Reads
45 Citations
17.810 Impact Factor

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

health care
28
structural constraints
8
safety strategies
8
care
7
health
7
safety
6
industries
6
reduce worker
4
workers reduce
4
discretion workers
4
system limit
4
care ultrasafe
4
ultrasafe industrial
4
industrial system
4
worker autonomy
4
limit discretion
4
mindset equivalent
4
senior leadership
4
leadership arbitration
4
arbitration optimize
4

Similar Publications